Customer Testimonials

Good

I had a check engine light in my vehicle. I took my car to another dealership multiple times, but the problem was never resolved. I brought it to Nissan. Matt, mechanic, did a thorough inspection and was able to identify the issue. He was fast with the repairs! I will definitely return for any future repairs!

My husband and I had a lot of fun buying a car from Halladay Nissan! We ended up going there three times before we made a decision. Tom, Damon, and Tyler helped us out and they were all low-pressure and very knowledgeable. We ended up liking a car color they didn't have and Tom actually drove down to a Nissan dealer near Denver to get it for us! I am so grateful I didn't have to spend my Sunday doing that! (Thank you Tom!) Overall, it was a very pleasant experience. Everyone was very nice. Shelby helped with ... Read More

Full review text opened.

Google - Nov 11, 2026

My husband and I had a lot of fun buying a car from Halladay Nissan! We ended up going there three times before we made a decision. Tom, Damon, and Tyler helped us out and they were all low-pressure and very knowledgeable. We ended up liking a car color they didn't have and Tom actually drove down to a Nissan dealer near Denver to get it for us! I am so grateful I didn't have to spend my Sunday doing that! (Thank you Tom!) Overall, it was a very pleasant experience. Everyone was very nice. Shelby helped with the financing and made it very quick. We got snacks, a great deal, got to test drive some fun cars, and left with an absolutely GORGEOUS vehicle. When our old car finally gives out, we'll be coming back!

I had just woke up was not fully awake but service was very good and service excellent

Excellent service representative and fast delivery

Good job to the crew for getting both of my Trucks serviced back to back. Thank you, Mike

Bryon and John are amazing! Always have a great experience at Halladay!

A little expensive but keeping my warranty. Friendly service and quick. They offer a shuttle service as well so that could increase the cost. Over all love it

Fast service, got everything working right again!

Great service, fast and friendly.

Fast,friendly,good with animals

Great place everyone professional

I've bought 2 vehicles in the past year from Halladay Motors. Im disappointed just because I feel I was loyal and came back to buy another vehicle and didnt feel like I was appreciated by company for discount on vehicle. Discount on vehicle wasn't much for my loyalty.

My family has been going to halladay motors for as long as I can remember. Their service was good when I was a kid, and even better now! Bryon, Shawn, and John were the best! They always make me feel at home and make the car buying experience top notch! I love my new Terrain!

Always excellent service

Thank you for all your help Robert, great customer service, thank you very greatful for Halladay motors.

Helped me find the perfect truck for me!

Great guy to work with!

Very fast great service good work thank you

I bought a 2019 Toyota Tundra last Friday. I was very impressed with staff. I was able to test drive, get approved for finance and be out the door in less than 2 hours. They were friendly and patient for I had never financed at a dealership before. On my way home I had my check engine light come on. I called the dealership and expressed my concerns and they immediately got it back into the shop for diagnosis. Since it was preexisting before purchase, the dealership is currently taking care of the problem with 0 cost to me. I am impressed with ... Read More

Full review text opened.

Google - Oct 19, 2026

I bought a 2019 Toyota Tundra last Friday. I was very impressed with staff. I was able to test drive, get approved for finance and be out the door in less than 2 hours. They were friendly and patient for I had never financed at a dealership before. On my way home I had my check engine light come on. I called the dealership and expressed my concerns and they immediately got it back into the shop for diagnosis. Since it was preexisting before purchase, the dealership is currently taking care of the problem with 0 cost to me. I am impressed with the fast and ethical response from the entire team. I even was able to get shuttled out of the dealership in order to go to work after dropping my vehicle off. Highly recommend to anybody looking to buy a new or used vehicle.

Cam has always taken good care of me and My husband. Bought my car through Halladay's only the best of the best works on my car.

Fast service. Streamlined checking in and out for me. GREAT price too.

Colt Anderson is the best sales guy I’ve ever worked with. He’s straight forward and he knows every one of the vehicles on the sales lot. He can BS with the best of them but when you leave with your new vehicle he’s explained everything and helped you setup the Onstar, Sirius radio and other things. That’s the reason he’s the salesman of the year every year. He cares about his customers and why I always go back when I’m ready for a new vehicle.

Nice of them to donate oil changes to foster families

Everyone I met and delt with were very friendly.

Excellent service as always. Cameron is the best!

Wonderful service, super friendly, did a great job in the time that they said and even included a car wash

I traveled 90 miles to have Halladay look at my Cadillac SRX. They diagnosed the problems early, and gave me the option to choose which repairs I wanted to do. The service writers were friendly and answered all of my questions. I am very impressed with their professionalism.

Tom Medina was amazing and helped me get my new Nissan versa thank you so much tom you were great

Always excellent care. Cam is so kind, efficient and courteous. As well as everyone else. We truly appreciate the extra cleaning.

Good place to buy a vehicle from. Salesman was great and explained everything. Price was pretty good tool

Excellent customer service in the shop area, especially from Cam.

Halladay dealership was great did all negotiations over the phone since we live in Colorado, and the dealership was in Cheyenne, Wyoming. Roger was amazing very responsive and communicated well. John also helped out in the sale and he kept to all his promises. Definitely go back whenever we do buy another vehicle had the amazing service. We were treated like if we were all one big happy family. Thank you Roger and John.

Diagnostics went well. Quotes for fixing issues were drastically overpriced. I was quoted 3400 for a clutch replacement by your shop and quoted half that by another reputable mechanic.

So I went up to Halladay Nissan in Cheyenne Saturday . So I went up there with a trade in and I knew exactly what I wanted to look at and what I wanted. When I got there I was meant to talk to Tom which ended up being busy so entrusted us to a guy named Tyler but really great guys. So after about an hour we were in talk on buying a 2017 Jeep Cherokee it was a nice clean ride and thats what I wanted. He got me approved and we were in process of haggling of course on ... Read More

Full review text opened.

Google - Jun 28, 2026

So I went up to Halladay Nissan in Cheyenne Saturday . So I went up there with a trade in and I knew exactly what I wanted to look at and what I wanted. When I got there I was meant to talk to Tom which ended up being busy so entrusted us to a guy named Tyler but really great guys. So after about an hour we were in talk on buying a 2017 Jeep Cherokee it was a nice clean ride and thats what I wanted. He got me approved and we were in process of haggling of course on at least lower payments on what I can afford. Then I told him my fiance has no credit but maybe adding alittle extra income plus help with credit score she possibly can be my Co signer. He said no problem he can definitely work with that. So after another 45 minutes we was getting antsy and said we are going outside to look around. We was walking around the lot cause it was a nice day looking at there really nice cars that I couldn't afford. About 30 minutes Tyler comes and tells us outside that they was still working on it and the bank they were talking to was fine but wanted a 6,000 dollar down payment which at the beginning I told i had no money for a down payment. He said yeah I told them that so we are talking with them trying to work something out. I was like sweet thank you. So about 30 minutes later we was back inside sitting in his office waiting on Tyler he come back and sits in his chair and tells us ,So we are still waiting on that but my sales manager really would like to talk to you about another possible option would be buying a newer model. He didnt seem too thrilled to tell me this. I looked over at my fiancé and muttered oh great. So then tyler went and got him he introduced him self and actually at this point to be honest I wont lie I didnt even really care what his name was. I know how the game works you where trying to make more money off me. I don't feel the need to disclose to my other financial issues here. We have a limited budget and I was straight up with him what I need to pay a month. And 500 to 600 a month on a car payment for a 2025 to 2026 vehicle I cant afford that and he knew that. I was already approved with what I had on the vehicle I wanted and I told him that but he proceeded to push a brand new car on me. Look I kinda know how the game works and I know what you where doing. How do they think i can barely afford a 400 a month payment for a 2017... but i can afford a 2026 500 dollar + payment. No since at all .So needless to say I walked away with out my sweet ride and I really want to point out Tyler and Tom the other sales lady that was very friendly as well. But that sales manager was pushing something that I couldn't afford when I was already approved for the car I wanted in the first place. Its pretty upsetting too cause I was willing to even over pay alittle more than I wanted to just because I liked that car so much. Tyler still would have got a nice little commission but the sales manager ruined that.

Came in to get my oil changed and asked if there was any way they could vacuum and they said that they didn't do that I wish they would have done that but other than that the service was fine

Bad experience. I don’t think you want a review from me.

You have the wrong number. I sent a stop command to the other text and I've answered calls telling you guys it's the wrong number. I'm not Michael. Maybe you'll be able to get this removed by acknowledging that I only know you exist from spamming my phone and have never shopped there? Anyways, have fun!

Poor service with subpar staff. When I asked about concerns they gave me very vague answers and did not give any effort to help with explaining compared to other shops I decided to go to instead. Wish there was an option for 0 stars.

I have been a Halladay customer for many years. The service and sales of both new and used vehicles has always been excellent, I'll continue being a customer because I know I don't have to be concerned about any of my dealings with Halliday..

Read at DealerRater

We are extremely disappointed with our experience at Halladay Nissan and would not recommend this dealership to anyone. Our vehicle was brought in for mechanical repairs, but it was returned to us with the same unresolved issue AND with a destroyed windshield. I called in advance of pickup to arrange payment, and at no point did anyone mention the damage. When my husband arrived to pick up the car he was nonchalantly informed that there had been a hailstorm, and they are not liable. According to a phone operator, the damage had occurred a week or two earlier, yet no ... Read More

Full review text opened.

Google - Oct 22, 2025

We are extremely disappointed with our experience at Halladay Nissan and would not recommend this dealership to anyone. Our vehicle was brought in for mechanical repairs, but it was returned to us with the same unresolved issue AND with a destroyed windshield. I called in advance of pickup to arrange payment, and at no point did anyone mention the damage. When my husband arrived to pick up the car he was nonchalantly informed that there had been a hailstorm, and they are not liable. According to a phone operator, the damage had occurred a week or two earlier, yet no one from the dealership contacted us to disclose or discuss it. We were told the damage was due to a hailstorm, but the condition of the windshield does not appear consistent with hail damage, as the rest of the car had no evidence of hail damage. Throughout this process, the maintenance department has been unprofessional, uncommunicative, and dismissive of their responsibility. This experience has completely undermined our trust. Save yourself the frustration — take your business elsewhere.

Service was performed in an expeditious manner. They kept me informed of the progress and answered all my questions. There were no surprises. The waiting area was comfortable and coffee and snacks were provided. A very good experience. Will definitely return for future service.

Read at DealerRater

very clean dealership friendly and helpful service righter needed a shuttle home was safe clean friendly and fast both ways home and back work was completed in a very timely manner the whole experience was pleasant and professional

Read at DealerRater

I dropped my car off for an oil change and a new headlight and walked out the door with a bill for $1000+. It's fine if parts and labor on the headlight really are $600 but in what world is it cool to spring that bill on someone without calling and saying "Hey here's the cost you're looking at for the headlight. You still want to go through with it today?" Instead the service counter just handed me the bill and said "Headlight was really expensive but you can't really drive around with it burned ... Read More

Full review text opened.

Google - Jun 23, 2025

I dropped my car off for an oil change and a new headlight and walked out the door with a bill for $1000+. It's fine if parts and labor on the headlight really are $600 but in what world is it cool to spring that bill on someone without calling and saying "Hey here's the cost you're looking at for the headlight. You still want to go through with it today?" Instead the service counter just handed me the bill and said "Headlight was really expensive but you can't really drive around with it burned out, right?". What is even worse was I called part way through the repair to see what time they thought it would be done this afternoon and they didn't say a word about the headlight expense. Normally I take my vehicles to a shop in Fort Collins because every needed repair is laid out with full price breakdowns and prioritized based on severity/importance. I authorize what I want done. I know exactly what it will cost. I thought I'd give the dealership here a chance though and save the time of driving. I regret that decision and will be taking my vehicles back to my preferred shop in Ft. Collins for service from now on.

Friendly and professional, treated us like family. Will recommend them to my friends and family.

Read at DealerRater

Came in due to weekend weird instance of warning lights on dash, called and got in on Monday to fix issues….

Read at DealerRater

This dealership was willing to stay with us after closing time. They also contacted us later by phone to see if the vehicle was still in good shape.

Read at DealerRater

Got to dealer one hour earlier than scheduled. They took the car in right away and finished the repair in less time than they thought it would take. The service machanic was very good.

Read at DealerRater

Outstanding service! The manager was amazing. He assisted in obtaining coverage from a third party warranty. We purchased the car and warranty from an out of state dealer who wouldnt honor the warranty they sold. Our next subaru will come from Hallady!

Read at DealerRater

Great help in choosing what needed to get done with a priority time. The rest could wait until April appt.

Read at DealerRater

Fantastic experience with Halladay, all the staff are friendly and helpful. I finally found a car that I wanted and Cesar was amazing!

Read at DealerRater

Cesar and Michael are two great salespeople extreme helpful, they went out of their way to help me make my purchase.

Read at DealerRater

My experience was positive. I got a great car and the process was exemplary. Andrew and Mike were great.

Read at DealerRater

Good service. Good transportation home while awaiting parts. Repair completed on schedule. Would recommend Subaru’s service department

Read at DealerRater

i LOVE THE WORK THEY DO WITH MY CAR They were very professional and polite

Read at DealerRater

They really take care of their customers needs and continually follow up worthy any issues they may have.

Read at DealerRater

Dealership went above the 'call of duty' in the process of installing accessories I had ordered.

Read at DealerRater

I asked through an email their best price on a truck. The salesman comes back with a price of 9000 more than the online price. So I ask why, he says you don't want that one you want the one I sent you a quote for. Bait and switch!! They lost a cash paying customer

Just a awful experience

Sales person Mark listened to my requirements, had multiple units to show me and ultimately found the one vehicle that had everything I wanted and fit my budget. Mike took me through everything else. No fuss, no muss. Very satisfied!

Read at DealerRater

Halladay Nissan had our car from May 8-May 13th for an a/c issue. We had the car returned only to find hundreds of window chips on the front windshield and down the passenger side. Pre photos do not show any damage, they put over 30 miles on the vehicle and yet they are refusing to say or do anything. Crickets. I normally am a person to stay quiet but I’ve seen bad people hurt good people so many times in the last few years I’m done. Do not give your service to this place. They have over 2k ... Read More

Full review text opened.

Google - May 16, 2024

Halladay Nissan had our car from May 8-May 13th for an a/c issue. We had the car returned only to find hundreds of window chips on the front windshield and down the passenger side. Pre photos do not show any damage, they put over 30 miles on the vehicle and yet they are refusing to say or do anything. Crickets. I normally am a person to stay quiet but I’ve seen bad people hurt good people so many times in the last few years I’m done. Do not give your service to this place. They have over 2k of our money and damaged our car beyond belief. These people are liars and thieves imo. I will continue to blast this company for as long as I have the absolute pleasure living in this city. Thanks for reading.

Lack of communication, overbooked in the service department so it took much longer than it should have.

This was the single worst car-buying experience I've ever had. We ultimately had to leave, go to Fort Collins subaru -and got a much better deal and phenomenal service. Two things were especially problematic. First, they gave us an estimated trade-in amount for our car (11k) but when we arrived wanted to give us 5k! They ultimately came back with an offer of 8k and said they were "taking a risk". Unbeknownst to them, we came in with 3 higher appraisals - and the car was in phenomenal condition. (Fort Collins subaru - i.e., Dellenbach - later ... Read More

Full review text opened.

DealerRater - Feb 20, 2024

This was the single worst car-buying experience I've ever had. We ultimately had to leave, go to Fort Collins subaru -and got a much better deal and phenomenal service. Two things were especially problematic. First, they gave us an estimated trade-in amount for our car (11k) but when we arrived wanted to give us 5k! They ultimately came back with an offer of 8k and said they were "taking a risk". Unbeknownst to them, we came in with 3 higher appraisals - and the car was in phenomenal condition. (Fort Collins subaru - i.e., Dellenbach - later offered us 10.4k and when we came in, we got 10.4k. No haggling, no pretending that the car wasn't in excellent shape, etc. In short - the offer we got was what every appraisal suggested it should be and what Dellenbach said it would be.) Second, they did that whole creepy thing where the sales person kept going back to another office to "try to get us a good deal" (they were probably talking about basketball) and kept lowballing us. The "back office" guy eventually came and hovered around our negotiations without saying anything. Super creepy. I'll keep my money in Wyoming whenever I possibly can. But had we stuck with Halladay (Cheyenne) instead of walking and going to Dellenbach (Fort Collins) - it would have cost us, conservatively, $2500. That's too high a price to pay for state loyalty. Will definitely go to Dellenbach in Fort Collins for future purchases. Halladay is old-school creepy car-buying experience. You can perceive yourself to have gotten a good deal at Halladay (because they'll tell you so) - but only if you haven't actually done your homework before going in - especially if trading in a car.

Read at DealerRater

Kassandra was extremely knowledgeable and helpful during the car buying process. The transaction was smooth and felt fair. The dealership is respectful and does a great job supporting the Subaru brand. Would buy here again.

Read at DealerRater

I was here looking at a new Subaru Crosstrek earlier today and was working with a woman named Katie she was very rude and unproffesional and even went to the extent of telling me i had to buy the car after i said i wanted to think it over and talk to my wife. Then i said i wasnt interested and she said that i was not areal buyer and that i couldnt afford it. I will no longer be taking my business here and will be filing a formal complaint and I guess i will have to go to ... Read More

Full review text opened.

DealerRater - Feb 8, 2024

I was here looking at a new Subaru Crosstrek earlier today and was working with a woman named Katie she was very rude and unproffesional and even went to the extent of telling me i had to buy the car after i said i wanted to think it over and talk to my wife. Then i said i wasnt interested and she said that i was not areal buyer and that i couldnt afford it. I will no longer be taking my business here and will be filing a formal complaint and I guess i will have to go to fort collins for my future business and needs. As a local dealership you should be ashamed to have someone like this working there and i am honestly in disbelief about the whole deal

Read at DealerRater

It’s been great (so far) dealing with these honest, engaging, personable people of HALLADAY Motors. They dealt factually and honestly in arriving at a fair price for a used car I was interested in. They gave up some-I gave up some - and the result is satisfaction for both parties.

Read at DealerRater

My Sales Person was Cassidy Fay at Halladay Subaru. I bought a new 2024 Subaru Outback XT from her and she and the team at Halladay could not have been more courteous and professional. I would recommend them to ANYONE and folks, the Outback is a SUPER SOLID PERFECT vehicle for this area. It is built so solidly and well!!! I plan driving it for 500,000 plus miles!!

Read at DealerRater

I apprediate the friendly greeting, prompt and professional manner in which they service my Outback. Thanks.

Read at DealerRater

I bought my Outback Wilderness because I got fed up with trying to deal with another brand. Ordered it online and got exactly what I wanted, right down to the color. I wasn’t counting on how well we’ve been treated ever since. Everybody is friendly and helpful, every time.

Read at DealerRater

After visiting a few local dealerships I’m glad I visited Halladay Subaru. From the minute we walked in they were so nice. Very knowledgeable with their inventory. Kassandra was great to work with. We feel like the whole process was refreshing. Loved that they even walked us thru the dealership for future visits for our regular maintenance that will be needed. Over all an amazing experience. Will definitely be back! Thank you Halladay.

Read at DealerRater

Honestly had such a good experience, I’ve never bought a car on my own, I was helped by Kassandra who made process so much less stressful!

Read at DealerRater

Carter was a very nice person and loved Kassandra's salesmanship.She was so nice and respectful

Read at DealerRater

Had an amazing experience with my purchase of my new Impreza! My salesperson Kassandra was very knowledgeable and Carter and Mike were beyond helpful!

Read at DealerRater

Had an amazing experience when purchasing my 2024 Outback Wilderness!! Carter (the sales manager) was extremely easy to work with and kept things fun. My sales representative, Cassidy, was so knowledgeable on the product and just amazing all around. I will definitely be purchasing here in the future 🙂

Read at DealerRater

These guys lie about what’s wrong with your vehicle to get more money out of you. I’ve been here twice for service. Neither time was I satisfied. The first time they said a sensor was unplugged which I know was not true because I installed it the day before. Check engine light was back on the same day I picked it up. The next time they told me that a thermostat was gonna fix the check engine light when they were completely separate issues. A thermostat has nothing to do with the ignition/timing system. So they blatantly ... Read More

Full review text opened.

Google - Nov 11, 2023

These guys lie about what’s wrong with your vehicle to get more money out of you. I’ve been here twice for service. Neither time was I satisfied. The first time they said a sensor was unplugged which I know was not true because I installed it the day before. Check engine light was back on the same day I picked it up. The next time they told me that a thermostat was gonna fix the check engine light when they were completely separate issues. A thermostat has nothing to do with the ignition/timing system. So they blatantly lied about what was wrong with my vehicle so I’d have to come back and pay the diagnosis fee again. Never going back here. They’re dishonest, can’t fix your car, and squeeze as much money as they can put of you.

My service appointments at Halladay Subaru have been excellent. I appreciate their timeliness and the explanation of everything done to the vehicle. I love the new service center and waiting area.

Read at DealerRater

Great experience! Garrett did a great job, supported by management and finance. We love the truck!

Read at DealerRater

I have been dealing with Halladay since Carl Halladay was running the place.I have always had success with your people or else it was made right..

Read at DealerRater

Entire staff was extremely helpful and professional. Special thank you to Vicki Holmstedt for her assistance.

Read at DealerRater

The purchase experience at Halladay is as good as it gets. Shawan efficiently explains all the post-purchase options, but is not pushy. This is just as it should be.

Read at DealerRater